Depressing to go up to an XXL when I wear a 10 in normal clothes and a 12 in Designer clothes. But the recommendation was correct. Great fit, not too bulky and not too snug. Lots of compliments today.

I received so many compliments on this sweater! Everyone (me included) loved how simple the sweater was but how modern it looked with the color block. I sized up per reviews and definitely needed to. This runs small. The sleeves were plenty long, however the body is not nearly as long as it looks in the stock photo. I didn't mind the length, but it wasn't a top I could wear with leggings. I didn't find this itchy or cardboardy as other reviewers did. I loved this and would rent it again!!

Not sure why this sweater has so many negative reviews. I thought it was the perfect dressed up turtleneck. I didn't find it scratchy and it's super cozy. Wore to a winery with friends and loved it so much I bought it!

I rented this for a trip to Alaska and loved it!

This sweater is just a great everyday winter sweater, perfect for a mountain weekend!

I am not a turtleneck fan but I LOVE this sweater. The sleeves are intentionally longer to allow for the color block detail. Warm without being overly hot making this a great fall or winter piece. I would keep this but I can't justify $177 on a sweater (and that's with the sale!). Planning to rent again in the fall

I loved this and want to keep it. I didn't find it scratchy like other reviewers. Fit great. Very warm

Perfect sweater to make any fall outing memorable! Not itchy either.

Runs large but true to size

Paired w black pants and red cords - very versatile. Simple.

I love this brand! But the sweater runs large and felt itchy and like it was made of cardboard. Wouldn't recommend.

I didn't realize this from the photos, but the sweater is a lighter navy blue than pictured. The fabric is super stiff and the arms are long. It fit awkwardly on me (pear, 5'2") and was bulky around the waist. All around not flattering.

Wore this many times throughout winter. Very comfortable, not too hot, and versatile look - polished, not too casual, not too dressy

Really cute and fun swear to wear with jeans. Fitted around tummy. Warm. Arms are a little long on purpose. If you have a bigger chest, I would size up.

Love this sweater! So much so that I ended up buying it. Great fit and weight. It is fitted, but not tight and a good length, hitting about at the hips.

I wore while 20-23 weeks pregnant and it was plenty long enough and very comfortable!

This is the perfect everyday sweater. I wore this to run errands, dinner with friends, and date night with my husband. It wasn't itchy and hit a good length on my hips.

The fit is loose but looks great with a pencil skirt, leggings, or even jeans. So versatile but just be ready to wear something underneath because it is itchy.

Good basic layer.

good for a ski weekend

I sized up and I'm glad that I did because it still felt a little tight. It was cute though so I'd rent again!

Nice piece. Very roomy as shown. Warm and cozy but not so bulky that a jacket won't fit. The fabric was a bit scratchy on the neck. Overall I enjoyed this sweater

Slightly less warm than other sweaters, but looked great.

This item fits smaller than I expected. I had to pull it down manually to get it to hit correctly at my hips. I did wear it a few times and it was cute but nothing outstanding. Probably would not rent again. Also a bit scratchy.

LOVED this sweater but it just didn't fit my 40D bust/ It was very snug and hugged my hips.

Cute design, small fit, itchy fabric

Beautiful sweater. A great fit. Professional looking. Just itchy.

Tight at hips but big and itchy elsewhere.

So itchy I couldn't wear it

I guess I'm spoiled by cashmere but I couldn't fathom wearing this fabric for more than 5 minutes. I'm sure it's a warm sweater but it's bulky and runs a bit small so was too fitted on me. For this kind of style. No go.

Super warm. Looks very sharp with a red lip and earrings.

Amazing sweater

The sweater is great for this time of year. It worked for work with dark pants, with jeans for an outdoor fall gathering and again for a clambake.

Loved this cozy fall sweater!

Waited for a while for this and it did not disappoint. Cute classic and very warm

Nice sweater but a little scratchy on the skin.

Loved the structured sleeves, which I wore both rolled up and down. The collar is flattering with hair up, and the navy/cream combo very versatile to wear. I received compliments from strangers when wearing this.

Really well made and cozy. I wore this several times in cold weather. I hated to send it back.

Its a little rough but not itchy and I'm SUPER sensitive to itchiness. Very warm and so cute. Considering buying it.

I loved this sweater and would have purchased it if it wasn't so expensive. I received a ton of compliments on it. I would size up one size if you want the slouchy look that is pictured on the RTR site. The material has potential to be a little scratchy. I wore a long sleeve t-shirt underneath and had no issues with comfort. I highly recommend this as a rental!