True to size. No stretch, but they do loosen up with wear

Love the style of these barrel leg jeans! Very comfy. I could have sized down, but will just wear with a belt for the remainder of my rental. Thick material with very little stretch. It was a bit warm at recess with my kindergartners.

I liked the way these jeans fit. Relaxed and casual, but easy to dress up. The waist was big, but not noticeable under baggy sweaters.

I was looking for a pair that wouldn't be too long for me and these were perfect. They were so cute and comfortable. Next time I would size down, I should have gone with waist size and not dress size. Also, the belt loops were too small for my belt in the front. Despite this, I can't wait to rent them again.

Only issue is that belt loops are tiny and only my smallest belt fit through the loops. Good length for petites.

Sweater is also RTR

Love these jeans so much I bought them after a couple months of not wanting to return. They arrived new with tags and fit so great. Just the right amount of baggy, but fitted in the high waist and seat. Very cute with cropped tops, sneakers, and booties. Love!!

They’re mine!! 😍

I rented a size up due to mine not being in stock. They did fit loose, but a belt helped and elevated the fit. They are not only cute, but very comfortable. I received numerous compliments on them. Including from a few teens! I will be purchasing these!

May buy but go down 1 size due to them being 100% cotton and stretching a little.

The front doesn't have zippers, it's three large buttons to hold it in place. Weird but still secure. But I quickly got used to it and this was very comfortable. A little oversized and long, but I'm 5ft so I'm used to it. Would size down if I rent again.

These jeans are stylish and comfy. They are button down not zipper.

Madewell jeans are consistently a really good fit for my body shape (which is a little thicker in the middle with narrower hips -- apple-ish I guess!). LOVE the fit and feel of these. They are on the shorter size -- worked fine for me at 5'5"ish but any taller than me and they'd def feel cropped fast. Like the wash. They are a button fly which I kind of hate so I docked one star for that. Still may wind up buying as they are prob the best button fly jeans I've ever found =) Would be 5 stars if they were a zipper!

Cool pants but yeah wish they were just a bit longer. Super comfy and this is my smaller size 25 and they were not tight, so go with your smaller jean size.

Wore 4-5mo pregnant, love the fit and style

Obsessed with these jeans but had to switch them out to a size down, I'd say they run at least 1 size big and when they stretch out a bit it's closer to 2 sizes big. With the right size, super cute!

These were slightly big, but I liked the baggier fit. I wore them 10+ times - super comfortable.

My first time trying barrel jeans. I loved these! I kept them for several shipments & almost bought them.

A little oversized. These are super comfy and stylish.

Tad larger than a 28, it fit just right on me, it would be comfy for a true 28. Good quality.

Perfect length for my 5'4", not cropped, but not bunching.

Flattering and comfortable jeans. Easy to throw on with any out fit and can easily dress up or down.

I received lots of compliments on these. I would size down, though, I got a 29 to be safe, and they were very big in the waist, but it kind of went with the look. I rolled them up to make them a bit shorter.

Great casual pair of jeans to wear with a cozy sweater

i thought these would not look good for my athletic build, but they were wonderful.

Only reason I'm not buying these is I've lost weight and want to try a smaller pair. Great jeans!

I always love Madewell jeans. Great quality. I loved the way these fit, but perhaps should have sized up for a more baggy look.

Loved the relaxed fit when sized up. Very comfy and cute barrel

Too short for winter, but perfect otherwise

So comfortable and stylish barrel jeans

I didn't realize I lost so much weight, but they were super cute!

Very comfortable and wore multiple times

Nice wash

Fit well, soft, did stretch a bit with wear so can definitely size down

So comfortable. Size down a bit.

True to size